Model projections, compared against the market

Tonight's Slate

October 10, 2026 — projected margins and win probabilities for every game, checked against DraftKings, Polymarket, and Kalshi. Updated Oct 10, 10:43 AM CT.
1Games
1Strong leans
0Moderate leans
0Toss-ups
7:00 PM CT
ALDS 'B' Game 5
Progressive Field
Chicago White Sox
84-78
Sean Burke
11-7, 3.34 ERA
@
Cleveland Guardians
85-77
Gavin Williams
14-8, 3.76 ERA
Projected margin
CLE -0.9 · CHW +0.9
Model fair odds
CHW +155 · CLE -155
Model Suggests Strong · 60.7%
Moneyline (Kalshi): Cleveland Guardians (KA -130) — model 60.7% vs. devigged market 56.5% (+4.2pp edge)
Model vs. Market DraftKings, Polymarket, Kalshi · current line
Model fairDraftKingsPolymarketKalshi
CHW ML+155 +118 +130 +130
CLE ML-155 -142 -130 -130
CLE -1.5+124+158——
First 5 innings Kalshi · current line · devigged · model projects CLE +1.0 thru 5
ModelModel fairKalshiKalshi oddsEdge
CHW leads32.2%+21137.7%+165-5.5pp
Tied16.2%+51917.6%+469-1.4pp
CLE leads51.7%-10744.7%+124+6.9pp
68°F wind 9 mph
CHW Projected CLE Projected

Why the Guardians. Don't read too much into the surface numbers on the mound — Gavin Williams (3.76 ERA, 1.11 WHIP, 248 K) has a better underlying profile than his ERA suggests, and we like him more than Sean Burke (3.34 ERA, 1.20 WHIP) tonight. Over the full body of work, the Guardians (85-77) grade out as the stronger club than the White Sox (84-78). The Guardians' lineup sets up well for this matchup, with its contact and plate discipline playing up tonight.

The case for the White Sox. The White Sox's relievers have the right stuff for this Guardians lineup — the pitch-mix matchup runs their way late.

Notes. Chicago White Sox note — Sean Burke: White Sox manager Will Venable said Friday that Burke will start Saturday in Game 5 of the ALDS versus the Guardians, Scott Merkin of MLB.com reports. Cleveland Guardians note — Gavin Williams: Williams will start Game 5 of the ALDS versus the White Sox on Saturday, Zack Meisel of The Athletic reports.

CHW CHW CHICAGO WHITE SOX — STARTING LINEUP & FIELD POSITIONS — Oct 10, 2026 ✦ ✦ ✦ PSeanBurke11-7 · 3.34 ERA · 172.1 IP1.20 WHIP · 185 SOCKyleTeel1BMunetakaMurakami2BChaseMeidroth3BMiguelVargasSSColsonMontgomeryLFSamAntonacciCFTristanPetersRFNot posted CHW @ CLE / Oct 10, 2026 ● position filled from today’s posted lineup · — not posted
8 of 9 positions confirmed
CLE CLE CLEVELAND GUARDIANS — STARTING LINEUP & FIELD POSITIONS — Oct 10, 2026 ✦ ✦ ✦ PGavinWilliams14-8 · 3.76 ERA · 184.1 IP1.11 WHIP · 248 SOCPatrickBailey1BNathanielLowe2BTravisBazzana3BJoséRamírezSSBrayanRocchioLFAngelMartínezCFStevenKwanRFChaseDeLauter CHW @ CLE / Oct 10, 2026 ● position filled from today’s posted lineup · — not posted
9 of 9 positions confirmed
CHW bullpen
PitcherERAWHIPSOGSVLast pitched
Sean Newcomb3.091.188460413d ago
Jordan Hicks3.941.546453114d ago
Anthony Kay4.441.3712933013d ago
Bryan Hudson3.741.285970814d ago
Grant Taylor2.251.07106601015d ago
David Sandlin5.581.21408016d ago
Davis Martin3.951.3212229014d ago
Tyler Davis3.661.162731114d ago
Noah Schultz5.571.336719014d ago
Hagen Smith1.290.964118015d ago
Erick Fedde3.831.359933017d ago
CLE bullpen
PitcherERAWHIPSOGSVLast pitched
Daniel Espino4.111.242514015d ago
Matt Festa3.781.316966115d ago
Erik Sabrowski2.611.187660115d ago
Tim Herrin3.021.315467015d ago
Shawn Armstrong4.581.393441014d ago
Hunter Gaddis2.981.285768115d ago
Joey Cantillo3.621.4217133016d ago
Cade Smith1.950.96107694114d ago
Tanner Bibee4.361.2214833014d ago
Foster Griffin3.601.2115831017d ago
Parker Messick2.561.0619332013d ago
CHW (away)
Projected · most recent complete lineup
BatterAVGHRRBIOPS
1Sam Antonacci LF.277848.766
2Kyle Teel C.210526.697
3Miguel Vargas 3B.2503393.837
4Munetaka Murakami 1B.2073577.825
5Andrew Benintendi DH.2401578.715
6Tristan Peters CF.2651256.774
7Kyle Teel C.210526.697
8Chase Meidroth 2B.2761663.765
9Colson Montgomery SS.1973187.685
CLE (home)
Projected · most recent complete lineup
BatterAVGHRRBIOPS
1Steven Kwan CF.282332.731
2José Ramírez 3B.2351253.688
3Chase DeLauter RF.2871667.820
4Jo Adell DH.2402394.699
5Nathaniel Lowe 1B.2521764.761
6Angel Martínez LF.2541862.755
7Travis Bazzana 2B.2451557.743
8Patrick Bailey C.2061037.607
9Brayan Rocchio SS.2531573.704