Model projections, compared against the market

Tonight's Slate

October 3, 2026 — projected margins and win probabilities for every game, checked against DraftKings, Polymarket, and Kalshi. Updated Oct 3, 2:29 PM CT.
4Games
2Strong leans
1Moderate leans
1Toss-ups
12:00 PM CT
ALDS 'B' Game 1
Progressive Field
Chicago White Sox
84-78
Hagen Smith
3-3, 1.29 ERA
@
Cleveland Guardians
85-77
Parker Messick
12-9, 2.56 ERA
Projected margin
CLE -0.1 · CHW +0.1
Model fair odds
CHW +111 · CLE -111
Model Suggests Lean · 52.7%
Moneyline (Kalshi): Chicago White Sox (KA +133) — model 47.3% vs. devigged market 43.0% (+4.3pp edge)
Model vs. Market DraftKings, Polymarket, Kalshi · current line
Model fairDraftKingsPolymarketKalshi
CHW ML+111 +124 +135 +133
CLE ML-111 -149 -135 -133
CLE -1.5+177+149——
First 5 innings Kalshi pregame close · devigged · model projects CHW +0.2 thru 5
ModelModel fairKalshiKalshi oddsEdge
CHW leads42.5%+13535.6%+181+6.8pp
Tied15.9%+53017.8%+461-2.0pp
CLE leads41.7%+14046.5%+115-4.9pp
64°F wind 7 mph
CHW Confirmed CLE Confirmed

Why the Guardians. The late innings tilt toward the Guardians, whose available relievers carry a 3.59 ERA against 3.75 for the White Sox. The Guardians' lineup sets up well for this matchup, with its contact and plate discipline playing up tonight.

The case for the White Sox. The edge on the mound belongs to the White Sox: Hagen Smith (1.29 ERA, 0.96 WHIP, 41 K) has been the better arm than Parker Messick (2.56 ERA, 1.06 WHIP). Hagen Smith's arsenal plays well against how this Guardians lineup has handled similar pitch mixes.

Notes. Chicago White Sox are going with a bullpen game: David Sandlin is lined up for the bulk innings behind opener Hagen Smith, so the relief matchup matters more than usual here.

CHW CHW CHICAGO WHITE SOX — STARTING LINEUP & FIELD POSITIONS — Oct 3, 2026 ✦ ✦ ✦ PHagenSmith3-3 · 1.29 ERA · 28.0 IP0.96 WHIP · 41 SOCKyleTeel1BMunetakaMurakami2BChaseMeidroth3BMiguelVargasSSColsonMontgomeryLFRandalGrichukCFBrentonDoyleRFBradenMontgomery CHW @ CLE / Oct 3, 2026 ● position filled from today’s posted lineup · — not posted
9 of 9 positions confirmed
CLE CLE CLEVELAND GUARDIANS — STARTING LINEUP & FIELD POSITIONS — Oct 3, 2026 ✦ ✦ ✦ PParkerMessick12-9 · 2.56 ERA · 186.1 IP1.06 WHIP · 193 SOCAustinHedges1BDavidFry2BTravisBazzana3BJoséRamírezSSBrayanRocchioLFAngelMartínezCFStevenKwanRFChaseDeLauter CHW @ CLE / Oct 3, 2026 ● position filled from today’s posted lineup · — not posted
9 of 9 positions confirmed
CHW bullpen
PitcherERAWHIPSOGSVLast pitched
Tyler Davis3.661.16273116d ago
Bryan Hudson3.741.28597086d ago
Sean Newcomb3.091.18846045d ago
Jordan Hicks3.941.54645316d ago
Noah Schultz5.571.33671906d ago
Grant Taylor2.251.0710660107d ago
Davis Martin3.951.321222906d ago
Erick Fedde3.831.35993309d ago
David Sandlin BULK5.581.2140808d ago
Sean Burke3.341.201853207d ago
CLE bullpen
PitcherERAWHIPSOGSVLast pitched
Tim Herrin3.021.31546707d ago
Erik Sabrowski2.611.18766017d ago
Cade Smith1.950.9610769416d ago
Hunter Gaddis2.981.28576817d ago
Shawn Armstrong4.581.39344106d ago
Daniel Espino4.111.24251407d ago
Matt Festa3.781.31696617d ago
Joey Cantillo3.621.421713308d ago
Foster Griffin3.601.211583109d ago
Gavin Williams3.761.112483207d ago
Tanner Bibee4.361.221483306d ago
CHW (away)
Confirmed · today's official lineup
BatterAVGHRRBIOPS
1Chase Meidroth 2B.2761663.765
2Randal Grichuk LF.2871546.880
2Tristan Peters LF.2651256.774
3Miguel Vargas 3B.2503393.837
4Munetaka Murakami 1B.2073577.825
5Tommy Pham DH.10013.429
6Brenton Doyle CF.233616.637
7Kyle Teel C.210526.697
8Braden Montgomery RF.226638.662
9Colson Montgomery SS.1973187.685
CLE (home)
Confirmed · today's official lineup
BatterAVGHRRBIOPS
1Steven Kwan CF.282332.731
2José Ramírez 3B.2351253.688
3Chase DeLauter RF.2871667.820
4Jo Adell DH.2402394.699
5Angel Martínez LF.2541862.755
6David Fry 1B.201820.677
6Nathaniel Lowe 1B.2521764.761
7Travis Bazzana 2B.2451557.743
8Austin Hedges C.247625.702
8Patrick Bailey PH.2061037.607
9Brayan Rocchio SS.2531573.704
3:00 PM CT
NLDS 'B' Game 1
UNIQLO Field at Dodger Stadium
Atlanta Braves
94-68
Dylan Dodd
4-1, 2.54 ERA
@
Los Angeles Dodgers
100-62
Tarik Skubal
12-7, 2.72 ERA
Projected margin
LAD -1.9 · ATL +1.9
Model fair odds
ATL +218 · LAD -218
Model Suggests Strong · 68.6%
Moneyline (Kalshi): Los Angeles Dodgers (KA -208) — model 68.6% vs. devigged market 67.5% (+1.1pp edge)
Model vs. Market DraftKings, Polymarket, Kalshi · current line
Model fairDraftKingsPolymarketKalshi
ATL ML+218 +173 +208 +208
LAD ML-218 -212 -208 -208
LAD -1.5-116-101——
First 5 innings Kalshi · current line · devigged · model projects LAD +1.5 thru 5
ModelModel fairKalshiKalshi oddsEdge
ATL leads26.1%+28326.2%+281-0.2pp
Tied15.9%+53014.9%+573+1.0pp
LAD leads58.1%-13858.9%-143-0.9pp
102°F wind 3 mph
ATL Confirmed LAD Confirmed

Why the Dodgers. The Dodgers' relievers have the right stuff for this Braves lineup — the pitch-mix matchup runs their way late. Don't read too much into the surface numbers on the mound — Tarik Skubal (2.72 ERA, 0.96 WHIP, 186 K) has a better underlying profile than his ERA suggests, and we like him more than Dylan Dodd (2.54 ERA, 0.91 WHIP) tonight. Over the full body of work, the Dodgers (100-62) grade out as the stronger club than the Braves (94-68).

Notes. Atlanta Braves note — Dylan Dodd: Dodd will serve as the opening pitcher Saturday during Game 1 of Atlanta's National League Division Series against the Dodgers, Mark Bowman of MLB.com reports. Los Angeles Dodgers note — Tarik Skubal: Skubal will start Game 1 of the NLDS against Atlanta on Saturday, Fabian Ardaya of The Athletic reports. Matt Olson is running cold over his last 10 games, batting .171 — .234 wOBA vs. a .393 season mark. Will Smith is running hot over his last 10 games, batting .382 — .502 wOBA vs. a .387 season mark. Freddie Freeman is running cold over his last 10 games, batting .195 — .205 wOBA vs. a .387 season mark. Atlanta Braves are going with a bullpen game: JR Ritchie is lined up for the bulk innings behind opener Dylan Dodd, so the relief matchup matters more than usual here.

ATL ATL ATLANTA BRAVES — STARTING LINEUP & FIELD POSITIONS — Oct 3, 2026 ✦ ✦ ✦ PDylanDodd4-1 · 2.54 ERA · 49.2 IP0.91 WHIP · 53 SOCSeanMurphy1BMattOlson2BOzzieAlbies3BAustinRileySSHa-SeongKimLFMauricioDubónCFMichaelHarris IIRFRonaldAcuña Jr. ATL @ LAD / Oct 3, 2026 ● position filled from today’s posted lineup · — not posted
9 of 9 positions confirmed
LAD LAD LOS ANGELES DODGERS — STARTING LINEUP & FIELD POSITIONS — Oct 3, 2026 ✦ ✦ ✦ PTarikSkubal12-7 · 2.72 ERA · 158.2 IP0.96 WHIP · 186 SOCWillSmith1BFreddieFreeman2BTommyEdman3BMaxMuncySSMookieBettsLFTeoscarHernándezCFAndyPagesRFKyleTucker ATL @ LAD / Oct 3, 2026 ● position filled from today’s posted lineup · — not posted
9 of 9 positions confirmed
ATL bullpen
PitcherERAWHIPSOGSVLast pitched
Victor Mederos3.411.19343016d ago
Robert Suarez1.060.88263346d ago
Dylan Lee3.090.97777106d ago
AJ Smith-Shawver6.611.5327906d ago
Raisel Iglesias2.551.086459346d ago
Brent Suter3.361.22785406d ago
JR Ritchie BULK4.911.47681716d ago
Didier Fuentes2.451.10925837d ago
Grant Holmes3.441.311153107d ago
Ray Kerr1.470.6011907d ago
Chris Sale2.160.982002709d ago
Tyler Mahle3.991.231372708d ago
LAD bullpen
PitcherERAWHIPSOGSVLast pitched
Alex Vesia2.641.07747236d ago
Brock Stewart2.701.01252816d ago
Tanner Scott2.690.998269256d ago
Evan Phillips3.461.08333116d ago
Edwin Díaz8.681.98282176d ago
Roki Sasaki4.491.321232606d ago
Edgardo Henriquez2.851.037161220d ago
Kris Bubic3.761.20561406d ago
Paul Gervase2.351.5784089d ago
Blake Snell1.901.1055906d ago
Yoshinobu Yamamoto2.530.871822809d ago
Tyler Glasnow3.530.95981308d ago
ATL (away)
Confirmed · today's official lineup
BatterAVGHRRBIOPS
1Drake Baldwin DH.2842579.817
2Ronald Acuña Jr. RF.2552055.796
3Ozzie Albies 2B.2372273.685
4Matt Olson 1B.2514193.823
5Michael Harris II CF.2942687.812
6Mauricio Dubón LF.2761273.720
7Austin Riley 3B.2191972.654
8Sean Murphy C.182310.556
9Ha-Seong Kim SS.11609.359
LAD (home)
Confirmed · today's official lineup
BatterAVGHRRBIOPS
1Mookie Betts SS.2572369.780
2Shohei Ohtani DH.2753081.889
3Will Smith C.2601034.781
4Freddie Freeman 1B.2881670.792
5Teoscar Hernández LF.2671664.759
6Kyle Tucker RF.2331770.715
7Andy Pages CF.2742385.811
8Max Muncy 3B.2522976.838
9Tommy Edman 2B.247842.714
5:30 PM CT
ALDS 'A' Game 1
Tropicana Field
New York Yankees
93-68
Gerrit Cole
10-9, 3.61 ERA
@
Tampa Bay Rays
98-64
Drew Rasmussen
16-5, 2.67 ERA
Projected margin
TB -0.6 · NYY +0.6
Model fair odds
NYY +139 · TB -139
Model Suggests Moderate · 58.2%
Moneyline (Kalshi): Tampa Bay Rays (KA -125) — model 58.2% vs. devigged market 55.5% (+2.7pp edge)
Model vs. Market DraftKings, Polymarket, Kalshi · current line
Model fairDraftKingsPolymarketKalshi
NYY ML+139 +112 +125 +125
TB ML-139 -135 -125 -125
TB -1.5+139+163——
First 5 innings Kalshi · current line · devigged · model projects TB +0.6 thru 5
ModelModel fairKalshiKalshi oddsEdge
NYY leads33.6%+19835.3%+183-1.8pp
Tied16.4%+50817.4%+474-1.0pp
TB leads50.0%+10047.3%+112+2.7pp
87°F wind 6 mph
NYY Confirmed TB Confirmed

Why the Rays. Drew Rasmussen's arsenal plays well against how this Yankees lineup has handled similar pitch mixes. The edge on the mound belongs to the Rays: Drew Rasmussen (2.67 ERA, 0.91 WHIP, 174 K) has been the better arm than Gerrit Cole (3.61 ERA, 1.10 WHIP). How the two bullpens line up tonight favors the Rays, with the arms they're likely to use in good shape.

The case for the Yankees. The Yankees' lineup sets up well for this matchup, with its contact and plate discipline playing up tonight. Over the full body of work, the Yankees (93-68) grade out as the stronger club than the Rays (98-64).

Notes. New York Yankees note — Ryan Weathers: Weathers (forearm) is listed on the Yankees' roster for their American League Division Series against the Rays. Tampa Bay Rays note — Cedric Mullins: Mullins isn't in the lineup Saturday for Game 1 of the ALDS against the Yankees. New York Yankees' starter has looked flatter lately — getting hit harder over his last 3 starts (23.9% called-strike+whiff rate, vs. 28.3% on the season). Luis García Jr. is running cold over his last 10 games, batting .189 — .226 wOBA vs. a .380 season mark. Spencer Jones is running cold over his last 10 games, batting .171 — .229 wOBA vs. a .400 season mark. Junior Caminero is running cold over his last 10 games, batting .257 — .316 wOBA vs. a .414 season mark. Liam Hicks is running cold over his last 10 games, batting .258 — .317 wOBA vs. a .382 season mark.

NYY NYY NEW YORK YANKEES — STARTING LINEUP & FIELD POSITIONS — Oct 3, 2026 ✦ ✦ ✦ PGerritCole10-9 · 3.61 ERA · 127.0 IP1.10 WHIP · 131 SOCAustinWells1BLuisGarcía Jr.2BJazzChisholm Jr.3BRyanMcMahonSSGeorgeLombard Jr.LFCodyBellingerCFTrentGrishamRFSpencerJones NYY @ TB / Oct 3, 2026 ● position filled from today’s posted lineup · — not posted
9 of 9 positions confirmed
TB TB TAMPA BAY RAYS — STARTING LINEUP & FIELD POSITIONS — Oct 3, 2026 ✦ ✦ ✦ PDrewRasmussen16-5 · 2.67 ERA · 172.0 IP0.91 WHIP · 174 SOCLiamHicks1BJonathanAranda2BRichiePalacios3BJuniorCamineroSSTaylorWallsLFChandlerSimpsonCFJonnyDeLucaRFVictorMesa Jr. NYY @ TB / Oct 3, 2026 ● position filled from today’s posted lineup · — not posted
9 of 9 positions confirmed
NYY bullpen
PitcherERAWHIPSOGSVLast pitched
Paul Blackburn1.591.08696218d ago
Brent Headrick2.181.21988108d ago
John Schreiber3.281.24406628d ago
Ryan Yarbrough3.691.22493838d ago
David Bednar2.471.047664358d ago
Will Warren3.921.371583208d ago
Ryan Weathers3.601.2214325042d ago
Carlos Rodón2.671.069116011d ago
Cam Schlittler1.950.922393308d ago
Max Fried2.800.9910420010d ago
TB bullpen
PitcherERAWHIPSOGSVLast pitched
Cam Booser1.980.76454206d ago
Kevin Kelly2.440.90637147d ago
Cole Sulser4.311.24565136d ago
Bryan Baker1.440.916365417d ago
Steven Matz5.491.23613616d ago
Tyler Wells2.380.907257621d ago
Garrett Cleavinger4.791.435451228d ago
Ian Seymour4.211.131584726d ago
Griffin Jax3.531.181163406d ago
Nick Martinez3.101.091093106d ago
Freddy Peralta4.421.331563207d ago
NYY (away)
Confirmed · today's official lineup
BatterAVGHRRBIOPS
1Ben Rice DH.2644197.897
2Cody Bellinger LF.2641773.767
3Luis García Jr. 1B.2773092.830
4Spencer Jones RF.2451140.742
5George Lombard Jr. SS.237722.699
6Jazz Chisholm Jr. 2B.2311955.711
7Trent Grisham CF.2111859.703
8Austin Wells C.1861432.624
9Ryan McMahon 3B.2131141.636
TB (home)
Confirmed · today's official lineup
BatterAVGHRRBIOPS
1Yandy Díaz DH.2932285.805
2Jonathan Aranda 1B.2742292.792
3Junior Caminero 3B.27642101.884
4Liam Hicks C.2841882.801
5Chandler Simpson LF.306038.689
6Victor Mesa Jr. RF.2601434.825
7Jonny DeLuca CF.2661150.729
8Richie Palacios 2B.2351057.704
9Taylor Walls SS.222236.607
7:30 PM CT
NLDS 'A' Game 1
American Family Field
San Diego Padres
91-71
Robbie Ray
13-8, 3.59 ERA
@
Milwaukee Brewers
103-59
Jacob Misiorowski
16-5, 1.80 ERA
Projected margin
MIL -0.8 · SD +0.8
Model fair odds
SD +151 · MIL -151
Model Suggests Strong · 60.1%
Moneyline (Kalshi): San Diego Padres (KA +182) — model 39.9% vs. devigged market 35.5% (+4.4pp edge)
Model vs. Market DraftKings, Polymarket, Kalshi · current line
Model fairDraftKingsPolymarketKalshi
SD ML+151 +171 +182 +182
MIL ML-151 -209 -182 -182
MIL -1.5+128+104——
First 5 innings Kalshi · current line · devigged · model projects MIL +1.0 thru 5
ModelModel fairKalshiKalshi oddsEdge
SD leads30.8%+22526.0%+285+4.8pp
Tied16.2%+51716.7%+500-0.5pp
MIL leads53.0%-11357.4%-134-4.3pp
56°F wind 5 mph
SD Projected MIL Projected

Why the Brewers. The edge on the mound belongs to the Brewers: Jacob Misiorowski (1.80 ERA, 0.80 WHIP, 252 K) has been the better arm than Robbie Ray (3.59 ERA, 1.35 WHIP). Over the full body of work, the Brewers (103-59) grade out as the stronger club than the Padres (91-71). The Brewers come in playing the better recent baseball, on both sides of the ball.

The case for the Padres. The late innings tilt toward the Padres, whose available relievers carry a 2.90 ERA against 3.52 for the Brewers.

Notes. San Diego Padres note — Robbie Ray: The Padres will start Ray in Game 1 of the NLDS against the Brewers on Saturday. Milwaukee Brewers note — Kyle Harrison: Harrison is listed on the Brewers' roster for their National League Division Series against the Padres.

SD SD SAN DIEGO PADRES — STARTING LINEUP & FIELD POSITIONS — Oct 3, 2026 ✦ ✦ ✦ PRobbieRay13-8 · 3.59 ERA · 165.2 IP1.35 WHIP · 140 SOCEthanSalas1BTyFrance2BJakeCronenworth3BMannyMachadoSSXanderBogaertsLFDustinHarrisCFJacksonMerrillRFFernandoTatis Jr. SD @ MIL / Oct 3, 2026 ● position filled from today’s posted lineup · — not posted
9 of 9 positions confirmed
MIL MIL MILWAUKEE BREWERS — STARTING LINEUP & FIELD POSITIONS — Oct 3, 2026 ✦ ✦ ✦ PJacobMisiorowski16-5 · 1.80 ERA · 174.2 IP0.80 WHIP · 252 SOCWilliamContreras1BJakeBauers2BBriceTurang3BJoeyOrtizSSCooperPrattLFJacksonChourioCFGarrettMitchellRFLuisLara SD @ MIL / Oct 3, 2026 ● position filled from today’s posted lineup · — not posted
9 of 9 positions confirmed
SD bullpen
PitcherERAWHIPSOGSVLast pitched
Yuki Matsui1.831.14685416d ago
David Morgan3.781.77393206d ago
Bradgley Rodriguez2.191.07816826d ago
Jason Adam2.621.17223827d ago
Adrian Morejon2.831.081077636d ago
Mason Miller1.670.9012966386d ago
Joe Musgrove736d ago
Randy Vásquez3.901.27873206d ago
Nick Pivetta2.861.0142808d ago
Michael King3.211.1815932010d ago
MIL bullpen
PitcherERAWHIPSOGSVLast pitched
Abner Uribe1.971.03626168d ago
Antonio Senzatela4.051.35605747d ago
JoJo Romero3.361.22545507d ago
Trevor Megill2.630.896963308d ago
Chad Patrick3.401.24935766d ago
Aaron Ashby3.121.311167547d ago
DL Hall1.911.04644706d ago
Kyle Harrison4.201.351412807d ago
Shane Drohan4.191.321253326d ago
Dustin May4.701.321443107d ago
Robert Gasser3.871.191032108d ago
Logan Henderson2.470.8411018010d ago
SD (away)
Projected · most recent complete lineup
BatterAVGHRRBIOPS
1Fernando Tatis Jr. RF.2892583.828
2Dustin Harris LF.293019.736
3Manny Machado 3B.2173091.710
4Jackson Merrill CF.2542687.743
5Ty France 1B.2952172.865
6Gavin Sheets DH.2121748.710
7Xander Bogaerts SS.2311357.676
8Jake Cronenworth 2B.225741.629
9Ethan Salas C.25625.737
MIL (home)
Projected · most recent complete lineup
BatterAVGHRRBIOPS
1Jackson Chourio LF.2912575.838
2Brice Turang 2B.26821100.816
3William Contreras C.2701894.758
4Gary Sánchez DH.2091238.771
5Jake Bauers 1B.2662686.873
6Luis Lara RF.246126.636
7Cooper Pratt SS.281334.718
8Garrett Mitchell CF.2621165.770
9Joey Ortiz 3B.270947.730